Image
Credit: Pexels
By Lilian H. Hill
We’re learning again what we always known: Words have consequences.”
President
Biden, March 19, 2021
The phrase
"words have consequences" reflects a widely understood concept about
the power of language and its impact on people and situations. While the quote may
not have a single origin, its essence is found in numerous historical and
philosophical texts and contemporary discussions. The phrase is particularly
relevant in misinformation, as it highlights the real-world impact of false or
misleading information on individuals and society. Misinformation, when spread
through various channels, especially social media, news outlets, and word of
mouth, can cause harm in several ways, mainly affecting people's beliefs,
actions, and decisions.
We are seeing the
results of misinformation in the ongoing recovery from Hurricanes Helene and
Milton, both of which made landfall in Florida. On September 26, Hurricane
Helene landed in the Big Bend region of Florida, near Perry, with maximum
sustained winds of 140 mph. Hurricane Milton made landfall with wind speeds of
120 mph on the west coast of the U.S. state of Florida, less than two weeks after Hurricane Helene. This blog
post was written two months after the hurricane events and old news in the information
ecosystem. It is daily life for the people who are dealing with the aftermath
of the hurricanes.
Following major
weather disasters, misinformation frequently surges. With Hurricane Helene
impacting several battleground states, the spread of false claims has
intensified. Some of the most extreme conspiracy theories circulating online
suggest that politicians manipulated the weather to target Republican regions
and that the government aims to seize land in North Carolina for lithium mining
(Tarrant, 2024).
Misinformation
during hurricane recovery has severe and far-reaching consequences, as it
complicates efforts to provide accurate information, distribute resources, and
ensure the safety of affected communities. For example, the Federal Emergency
Management Agency, or FEMA, had to address the rumor that the $750.00 Serious Needs
Assistance would be the only assistance hurricane victims would receive. In
reality, Serious Needs Assistance is dispersed for “upfront, flexible payment
for essential items like food, water, baby formula, breastfeeding supplies, medication
and other serious disaster-related needs” (para. 1).
Following that, “FEMA may provide money and
other services to help you recover from losses caused by a presidentially
declared disaster, such as damage to your home, car, and other personal items.”
FEMA can provide funds for temporary housing, repair or replacement of owner-occupied
homes for primary
residences, temporary housing, and hazard mitigation assistance, depending on individual needs. Rumors
about limited assistance can prevent people from applying for the help they
need. The problem is so pervasive that FEMA maintains a Hurricane Rumors Response
webpage in 12 languages that is updated with each new hurricane landfall.
Some keyways in which misinformation impacts hurricane recovery include:
1. Public Safety Risks
Misinformation about evacuation orders, shelter availability, or road conditions can put lives at risk. For example, if false information spreads that certain areas are safe to return to when they are not, people might expose themselves to dangerous flooding, structural instability, or other hazards. Similarly, misleading updates about ongoing storms can leave people unprepared for secondary dangers like storm surges or flash floods.
2. Strain on Emergency Services
False claims about the availability of emergency services or relief supplies can overwhelm first responders. People must be more informed about where they can receive aid or assistance to avoid flooding the wrong locations or resources, further straining already limited services. In extreme cases, this can divert attention from critical rescue efforts or supply distribution, delaying recovery for those in real need.
3. Confusion Around Relief Resources
Misinformation about accessing federal or state disaster relief can hinder recovery efforts. False claims about the steps needed to apply for financial assistance (e.g., FEMA aid), insurance processes, or donation sites may lead to frustration and slow the distribution of funds and resources. Additionally, scammers often take advantage of these situations, spreading fake donation links or relief fund drives, which siphon resources away from legitimate efforts.
4. Economic and Community Impact
Post-hurricane recovery efforts often rely on accurate information about damaged infrastructure, business reopening, and rebuilding efforts. Misinformation about these topics can lead to prolonged economic hardship for communities, as people may hesitate to return or invest in rebuilding due to fear or uncertainty caused by false information. Additionally, misinformation about insurance claims or rebuilding permits can delay recovery for homeowners and businesses.
5. Health and Well-being
During recovery, misinformation can affect the physical and mental health of individuals. For example, false information about contaminated water sources, unapproved medications, or unverified health risks can cause unnecessary fear or lead people to take inappropriate actions that worsen their situation. In some cases, rumors or unverified claims about medical conditions (such as exposure to mold or diseases post-hurricane) can prevent people from seeking proper medical care.
In summary, misinformation during hurricane recovery can exacerbate existing challenges, delay crucial response efforts, and even result in loss of life. It underscores the importance of accurate communication and the responsible sharing of information during disaster response.
References
Biden, J. (2021, March 19). Remarks by President Biden at Emory University. White House Briefing. Retrieved https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2021/03/19/remarks-by-president-biden-at-emory-university/
FEMA (2024, October 8). Addressing Hurricane Helene Rumors and Scams. Retrieved https://www.fema.gov/blog/addressing-hurricane-helene-rumors-and-scams
Tarrant, R. (2024, October 7). Misinformation has surged following Hurricane Helene. Here's a fact check. CBS News. Retrieved https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hurricane-helene-fact-check-misinformation-conspiracy-theories/
